Tuesday, January 26, 2010

Monday, January 25, 2010

The Best Sounds for Getting Work Done - Music - Lifehacker

The Best Sounds for Getting Work Done

The right kind of sound can relax your mind, hone your focus, drown out distractions, or get you pumped to kill your to-do list. We've assembled some research and free resources to help you create your own best workspace soundtrack.

Photo by Sara Björk.

Does music really make you more productive?

The answer falls somewhere between "Listening to Mozart makes you a genius" and "Just be quiet and work."

The most often cited study into the question of music's effect on the mind involves the so-called Mozart effect, which suggests that listening to certain kinds of music—Amadeus Wolfgang's classical works, in particular—impacts and boosts one's spatial-temporal reasoning, or the ability to think out long-term, more abstract solutions to logical problems that arise. The Mozart effect has been overblown and over-promised, and even outright refuted as having "bupkiss" effect, but that doesn't mean a great mind-juicing playlist can't be created.

The Workplace Doctors site details both sides of the question. In one study, University of Illinois researchers found that listening to music in "all types of work" increased work output 6.3% over a control group. In another study (dissected at MetaFilter), 56 employees working on basic computer tasks were found to be more productive when there was no music playing over the same period tested with music.

So the real answer turns out to be, unfortunately, "it depends." It depends on whether your office or workspace is noisy enough that a good kind of noise or music is preferable to the natural cacophony. It depends on your personal attention span, and how likely you are to fiddle with controls versus letting a music stream trickle past your ears. Though many of the final answers to studies of music at work conflict, the general consensus seems to be that people can be boosted at work by music, if they're willing to be.

If that sounds like you, here's a few suggestions on where to find music that others have found helpful in their own workspaces.

The classical route

How it works: The ornate instrumentation and composition of Baroque classical music gets a lot of attention for its possible mind-boosting effects. Eight radiologists were asked to go about their day while listening to Baroque-period tunes. They mostly self-reported better mood and productivity, except for one worker who said the music had a negative effect on his concentration.

Followers of Getting Things Done and productivity writer David Allen note in forum posts that the man himself seems to dig Vivaldi's "Four Seasons," Bach's Brandenburg Concerto #3, and other Baroque tunes as mood-setters for tackling tasks like a weekly review. A key suggestion from a David Allen forum poster—look for tracks paced at about 60 beats per minute:

It's the beats-per-minute required to get the brain up to optimal revs. David has a segment about it on GTD Fast – I also came across it at a speed-reading class. It seems to cause a "bright and breezy" frame of mind where thinking and creativity are easier. I find it works.

Where to get it: Being often hundreds of years old and a niche interest these days, classical music is relatively easy to find online. Wikipedia has hundreds of freely-licensed files, and public domain search sites like Musopen offers a lot of good stuff, too.

If the Baroque sound doesn't quite do it for you, Lifehacker commenter Catalyst suggests the Vitamin String Quartet, which covers pop tunes in string quartet/chamber music style. It's not the same kind of down-deep arrangement as traditional classical work, but the Quartet's work takes away distracting lyrics and soothes out pop music's more annoying edges. Here's a sample:

The ambient/techno route

How it works: The label "ambient" has been applied far too broadly to be of much help to anyone but record store owners. Still, at its core, all ambient music is designed not to jump in your face, but still keep your brain engaged at a lower, subconscious level. Pioneers like Brian Eno developed ambient music as an experiment in composition, allowing algorithms, randomness, synthesizers, and whatever sounded neat to replace the standard components of pop music.

A modern variant, chillout, and its categorical cousins downtempo, ambient house, and certain varieties of IDM, or Intelligent Dance Music, grew out of a need for dancers and partiers at techno clubs to take a break, relax, and recover from their efforts, along with whatever else they needed recovering from. Like the original ambient music, much of it is designed to relax the mind and allow it to roam, while providing just enough stimulation to register as inspiration.

Where to get it: Both Gina and Brian Ashcraft at our gaming-focused sibling blog Kotaku find Eno's Music for Airports to be superior music for deep tasks and serious studying. It was designed, after all, for actual airports, to put passengers at ease in an often stressful situation, right before getting on a tube that some consider their worst fear.

Gina and many, many commenters dig the Groove Salad stream and other stations, like Drone Zone and Secret Agent, provided by Soma.fm. Half as many recommend the ambient offerings at Digitally Imported, and often flip between it and Soma.fm for fresh streams. Both sites provide free audio to most any music player that can tune in web playlists or radio.

If you're a fan of streaming recommendation site Pandora, or like the minimalist, "glitch," or seriously ambient side of techno, commenter maczter recommends a playlist created by a Pandora employee, Ovals, that he describes as "minimalist elemental glitch." I tried it out for an afternoon writing session, and found five out of six tracks to be unexpectedly calming and helpful in the task—with the exception of one rather jarring, high-pitched interloper.

The noise route

How it works: If music is too distracting for your tastes, but your chatty co-workers, office machinery, and general clamor are even more distracting, colored noise might be a worthy addition to your audio repertoire.

Noise generators, usually grouped into groups of white, pink, or brown/red, cover a range of your ear's audible spectrum with generic sound to mask or lessen the distractions of other sounds. Wikipedia's entry on sound masking puts it best:

Imagine a dark room where someone is turning a flashlight on and off. The light is very obvious and distracting. Now imagine that the room lights are turned on. The flashlight is still being turned on and off, but is no longer noticeable because it has been "masked". Sound masking is a similar process of covering a distracting sound with a more soothing or less intrusive sound.


Where to get it: If you can install desktop software where you work, we've previously recommended Noise for Mac OS X and Chatterblocker for Windows as great apps for covering up sounds. Noise creates more straight-up sound waves, while Chatterblocker can recreate office environment noise to fill in notable gaps or introduce other ambient-type sounds, like guitar chords and nature, into your mix.

On the web, we're also partial to Zendesk's Buddha Machine Wall, which randomizes and loops relaxing sounds that you choose from among random buttons and speakers. For a more pure white/pink/brown noise generator, try SimplyNoise.

Lost in a sea of random speaker crackle? Editor's tests have found that pink noise generally simulates a waterfall effect, while setting the brown/red noise in SimplyNoise to a low volume, while allowing the volume to fall up and down, or oscillate, provides a soundscape similar to waves hitting the shore off in the distance.

Other routes

We asked our readers to share the music that helps them get things done, and they showered us with responses. There are a lot of specific artists, albums, and genres listed in the comments of that post that might inspire you to re-seed your own playlist, but a few had some unique ideas on what helped them listen while stay productive.

four12 wrote that listening to radio stations in foreign languages "effectively drowns out the office noise, but because I really don't understand what is being said (though I am learning), my brain tunes even that out." In his case, France Info radio provides the news-but-not-really-news he needs.

wowser808, on the other hand, goes with a more traditional, and heart-warmingly geeky, pic: the Blade Runner soundtrack." He notes that Vangelis' ethereal tunes "got me through every single essay at university."

We are still more than open to your suggestions of what music, noise, random sounds, or audio hackery makes for the most productive environment. Tell us your picks in the comments.

Send an email to Kevin Purdy, the author of this post, at kevin@lifehacker.com.


Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

I love Secrets of Zen - Japanese Chillout Vol. 1 - it really does help me to put a calm ambient wall of sound between me and the rest of the herd in my company open space:

[www.gomusicnow.com] Reply


I am a programmer and I love listening to trance/progressive dance music that either I make or from other, popular DJs. Not too fast but a good pace of music which goes on interesting journeys - kind of like ambient but with more of a beat!

It helps me focus on my coding and keeps my pace of work going, I can sometimes code solidly from morning to lunch barely realising the time :)

If anyone is interested they can download my mixes for free here:
[soundcloud.com]

I hope you enjoy them! Reply

Barts approved this comment

@Alex Gemmell: Wow, some of these mixes are really good.

Thanks for making them publicly available in reasonable bitrate. Reply


@Alex Gemmell: There's some kind of connection between Trance and programming -- I've been doing this same thing since 2001, really helps your productivity. Reply
Barts promoted this comment

I subscribe to the Hearts of Space website (www.hos.com): Their radio channel has proven really productive for me: Space music is awesome, provides ambient unfocused noise (not many dramatic music swells like in the Moby/String Quartet clip above), plus really great tunes. I usually listen to the radio channel at work (or pick out my "favorite episodes" and play those over and over), but admittedly I have to skip over the programs that have chamber music (western/eastern monks chanting) or singing/chanting stuff (some of the native american-themed programs) as they are distracting to my workflow. However, due to HOS, I was able to find and get into some awesome artists, like Lisa Gerrard, Steve Roach, and Mercan Dede: [www.youtube.com] Reply


The work environment is a very important and powerful factor that influence productivity. Do your best to create a pleasant work environment and the chances of increasing productivity will be much higher. Me for example, sometimes I do not stand any music, I simply cannot focus on my work, for me, in these moments the music is a productivity killer Reply
Barts promoted this comment

I can't recommend Explosions In The Sky highly enough. Their music has a seemingly epic feel to it that makes you feel like someone has written an epic soundtrack to accompany the menial task that you are accomplishing at your desk, while the lack of lyrics helps you stay on task.

For some variety, I've found that an Explosions station on Pandora has exposed me to some other non- electric guitar based bands that I've grown to enjoy.

On the band's website, you can download a free album: [www.explosionsinthesky.com]

It's not their best stuff, but it'll give you an idea of what to expect. A couple of the songs do have a few voiceovers, but this is highly unusual for them.

FWIW, "The Earth Is Not A Cold, Dead Place" is my favorite album of theirs to study to. Reply


Where is the METAL?!

Actually, listening to metal might explain my tons in half of my comments... haha Reply

Edited by UnderLoK at 09/22/09 11:52 AM

@UnderLoK: "tone"

Was preoccupied with Roto Rooter telling me they have to jet my sewer for $520... bastards Reply


Kevin & Lifehacker, I'm lovin' these sonic posts! I'm a big believer in using the right sounds to accomplish in pounds!

Let me just say that the Halo and Metal Gear Solid themes make email a lot more epic!

On the minimal glitch tip, if you love pianos with subtle electronics, Ryuichi Sakamoto + Alva Noto's collaborations are a MUST. Full of beauty and space.

As a composer, I've also found it invaluable — when I can't find anything else that fits my mood — I make my own music, including relaxing piano which helps me unwind both by playing and listening to it. Ah, resourcefulness! Reply

Edited by Torley at 09/22/09 10:00 AM

I agree with the Vitamin String Quartet. Every now and then, you can pick up the song subconsciously, but it provides a nice background playlist when you're really busy.

Plus, they cover some already instrumental-heavy bands, such as Radiohead and the Mars Volta. Reply

Torley promoted this comment

@bilk: VSQ are INCREDIBLY prolific. So many tribute albums. I wish they applied more creative processing at times, like Apocalyptica does with Metallica. But I giggled with glee upon VSQ's cover of Fall Out Boy's "Thanks For The Memories!" Reply


In order to view comments on lifehacker.com you need to enable JavaScript.
If you are using Firefox and NoScript addon, please mark lifehacker.com as trusted.

Just came across this old post from Lifehacker about Ambient sound and Productivity. One of my favorite online radio stations is mentioned...

Posted via web from Robert Alan Anderson